...

Why New York Times’ attack on bitcoin mining is wrong

Apr 19, 2023 | Updates

The New York Times (NYT), a reputable newspaper, recently published an article that drew criticism for its claims about bitcoin miners. The piece asserted that the bitcoin mining industry produces significant greenhouse gas emissions and that miners profit from problems with the American power grid. While some of these claims have merit, the article lacked […]
  1. Home
  2.  | 
  3. Updates
  4.  | Why New York Times’ attack on bitcoin mining is wrong

The New York Times (NYT), a reputable newspaper, recently published an article that drew criticism for its claims about bitcoin miners. The piece asserted that the bitcoin mining industry produces significant greenhouse gas emissions and that miners profit from problems with the American power grid. While some of these claims have merit, the article lacked nuance and context, according to researchers such as Daniel Batten.

New York Times makes bold claims about bitcoin miners

In the article, NYT presents its case for what “the real-world costs” are of bitcoin mining. It starts the story with the winter storm that recently shook Texas, causing 40 deaths due to a lack of electricity. The author, Gabriel Dance, then goes on to tell that just outside of Austin, a large bitcoin mining farm was mining BTC and thus using electricity.

At midnight, the local government ordered the mining farm to shut down. This is part of an agreement that helps free up more capacity on the grid. In return, the mining operation is rewarded for shutting off its machines.

NYT then presents several facts to build its case further and compares the consumption of mining farms with households. The newspaper claims that Riot, a large mining company, uses as much electricity as 300.000 households. But is this a bad thing? No, says Riot. It can “shut down at a moment’s notice,” making electricity available to households. Riot states that it is not being paid for the promise of shutting down its BTC miners when requested, but instead:

“Riot is not compensated for “promises,” we are compensated for providing ERCOT [Texas] the ability to manage Riot’s energy load directly.”

Bitcoin can help stabilize the grid

Mining bitcoin does use a lot of electricity. But it is the source of that electricity that makes mining polluting or not. In the case of Texas, which has a relatively green power grid, miners can help stabilize the grid.

Miners do this by acting as a demand response tool that can help balance the supply and demand of electricity during periods of high or low energy consumption. This is accomplished by using the miners to consume excess energy that would otherwise be wasted during periods of low demand and reducing their energy consumption during peak demand.

In practice, this could look like a utility company partnering with a bitcoin mining operation to utilize its excess energy capacity during off-peak hours. The utility company would offer a lower price for electricity during these times to incentivize the miners to ramp up their energy consumption. During peak demand, the utility company could offer a higher price for electricity to incentivize the miners to reduce their energy consumption or even temporarily shut down their operations.

This system can benefit both the power grid and the bitcoin miners. The power grid would be able to balance its supply and demand more efficiently, reducing the risk of blackouts. The bitcoin miners, in turn, could take advantage of cheaper energy prices during off-peak hours, leading to lower operating costs and increased profitability.

GRN Energy can help you make your operation more sustainable. Read more about our approach to learn what GRN Energy can do for you. If you have any question, feel free to reach out to our support!

Other articles

Jun 25 2025

GRN Energy Launches Unfold 3 Solutions: Customizable Modular Infrastructure for Data Centers, Vertical Farming & Housing

GRN Energy Launches Unfold 3 Solutions: Customizable Modular Infrastructure for Data Centers, Vertical Farming, & Housing PITTSBURGH, PA, UNITED STATES, June 24,...
Jun 04 2025

Bitcoin Las Vegas 2025

The Bitcoin 2025 Conference, held from May 27–29, 2025, at The Venetian Resort in Las Vegas, was the largest global gathering of Bitcoin enthusiasts, drawing over...
Feb 26 2025

How MiCA and U.S. AI Export Rules May Shape the Future of Bitcoin, AI, and HPC Data Centers

Understanding MiCA (Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation) The Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA), effective December 2024, introduces a unified framework for...
Jan 28 2025

Navigating President Trump’s Executive Orders: Opportunities and Risks in Crypto, AI, and Energy

President Donald Trump has initiated several executive orders aimed at reshaping the regulatory landscape for the cryptocurrency, blockchain, artificial intelligence...
Nov 24 2024

Top 12 Global Data Center Locations

The ideal location for a data center depends on a company’s operational, executional, and financial capabilities. What works for one organization may not align with the...
Nov 15 2024

Web Summit 2024: Premier Tech Conference with 70,000+ Attendees

eb Summit is widely recognized as one of the top global tech conferences, bringing together thousands of attendees, investors, and companies. The event not only...
Oct 21 2024

How Localizing Infrastructure could shape the Future of Digital Evolution and Sustainable Growth?

Localizing infrastructure, such as microgrids and data centers, could play a pivotal role in shaping the future of digital evolution and sustainable growth. As...
Oct 14 2024

Key Trends in Crypto Mining Acquisitions: Insights and Forecasts for 2024

We hope this article and analysis provide valuable guidance for future mining acquisition decisions and help forecast trends for growth in the sector. Companies that...
Sep 29 2024

Pioneering Clean Energy: A Global Initiative to Power Islands with 5 GW Solar & 3 GW Wind

We are pleased to announce our participation in a collective group of companies dedicated to reducing the use of fossil fuels on islands worldwide. Our group will...
Jul 29 2024

Scaling Your Bitcoin Mining Data Center: From Tier 0 to Future-Ready

This guide provides insights on optimizing Bitcoin mining operations by upgrading Tier Zero data centers. Key strategies include improving power delivery, cooling...